This week:

• The Federal Maritime Commission’s landmark decision promoting fairness in container transportation.
• Geopolitical tensions and security concerns lead to major shifts in Red Sea shipping routes.
• The Panama Canal demonstrates resilience and operational improvements, overcoming previous disruptions and reinforcing its crucial role in global trade pathways.
• US truckload carriers strategically reduce their capacity in response to sustained low freight demand.
• Industrial real estate market dynamics are characterized by soaring rents and a deceleration in construction starts.

FMC Ruling Reshapes US Container Transport Landscape

In a decisive verdict favoring the American Trucking Associations (ATA) over the Ocean Carriers Equipment Management Association (OCEMA), the Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) has issued a directive prohibiting ocean carriers from obligating cargo owners and their trucking partners to employ designated chassis for merchant haulage operations. This ruling, delivered through a 4-1 vote, marks a pivotal transition towards fostering fairer competition and equity within the realm of container transportation logistics.

This dispute centered on the distinction between carrier haulage and merchant haulage agreements. Under carrier haulage, the ocean carrier oversees the complete door-to-door transport of cargo. In merchant haulage, the carrier manages only the sea and port segments, leaving inland transportation to the cargo owner. 

The FMC’s decision is a victory for competition and fairness in the supply chain. 
This decision also addresses broader jurisdictional questions, affirming the FMC’s authority over container transport practices beyond port boundaries. 

Sign up to Receive JMR’s Supply Chain News Roundup, Delivered Directly to Your Inbox Weekly

Red Sea Shipping Disruptions Impact Saudi and Egyptian Importers

The redirection of ultra-large container ships away from the Red Sea is creating significant logistical challenges for Saudi and, to a lesser extent, Egyptian importers. The diversion, primarily due to concerns over Houthi militant attacks, has forced a reliance on feeder networks, causing delays in shipments and increasing costs. 

Despite the ongoing threats, the Suez Canal route to Jeddah Islamic Port remains open for southbound voyages, deemed safe from attacks due to the considerable distance from conflict zones. However, the shift from ultra-large vessels, capable of carrying over 15,000 TEUs, to feeder vessels, which typically handle up to 5,000 TEUs, represents a significant reduction in capacity and efficiency for the region.

The Houthi offensives, which began in mid-December, have led to an estimated 30% to 40% reduction in container capacity in the Red Sea, significantly affecting trade flows and operational logistics. In response, some smaller shipping lines are taking calculated risks to maintain operations through the Red Sea, exploiting the opportunity to charge higher rates amidst the heightened risk and demand for alternative routes.

Easing Disruptions in the Panama Canal: A Turn for the Better

The Panama Canal, a critical conduit for global trade, has witnessed a significant improvement in operations, alleviating the concerns of shippers affected by prior disruptions. Initially, shippers across Asia and the Americas faced delays, with carriers forced to divert routes or transship cargo due to low water levels impacting the canal’s capacity. This resulted in shipment delays of up to a month. 

However, recent developments have seen a positive change, with carriers like Hapag-Lloyd and Ocean Network Express (ONE) resuming transits and even discontinuing the Panama Canal contingency surcharge for US and Canadian exports, signaling operational improvements.

Hapag-Lloyd announced that THE Alliance had resumed transits through the Panama Canal on its EC2 service, connecting Asia with the US East Coast. Similarly, ONE confirmed full restoration of Panama Canal transits on this route, starting with the Tayma Express. 

This adjustment has allowed for at least four eastbound EC2 services to utilize the canal in February. Moreover, the EC6 service, connecting US Gulf ports with Asia, has also shifted back to canal transits, reflecting a case-by-case decision-making process based on canal booking availability.

Adjusting to Market Realities: US Truckload Carriers Cut Capacity

In response to persistently low freight demand, major US truckload providers are strategically reducing their available capacity, a trend highlighted by the latest figures from the Journal of Commerce Truckload Capacity Index. 

The index fell to 80.8% in the fourth quarter, marking its lowest level since early 2018 and showcasing a significant 8.7 percentage point year-over-year drop. This decline reflects the largest annualized decrease observed in the current cycle, underscoring a deliberate shift towards rebalancing capacity akin to the “normal” market dynamics experienced during 2017-2018.

The capacity contraction among large truckload carriers, which collectively generated over $5 billion in revenue in 2023, comes amidst a broader exodus of smaller fleets from the industry. 

Despite this, the significant players in the market are not merely waiting for these departures to rebalance the supply-demand equation in their favor. Instead, they are proactively optimizing their operations to lower execution costs. For instance, Werner Enterprises has prioritized refining its business model to focus on more profitable ventures, resulting in a 7% reduction in its truck count year over year in the fourth quarter, even as it managed to improve miles per tractor by 9%.

Similarly, Knight-Swift Transportation Holdings has shed approximately 1,300 tractors over the past year to curtail expenses while enhancing the efficiency of its remaining fleet. Meanwhile, companies like Covenant Logistics are exploring expansion opportunities, such as the acquisition of Lew Thompson & Son Trucking, with plans to further grow this segment.

Record-High Warehouse Rents in the US Amidst Evolving Market Dynamics

The landscape of the US industrial real estate market experienced a significant milestone in 2023, with warehouse and distribution space rents soaring to a record $9.72 per square foot, reflecting a 20.6% year-over-year increase, as reported by Colliers. 

This surge in asking rents is occurring in a backdrop of persistently low vacancy rates, despite the introduction of a substantial volume of new industrial space into the market. Colliers anticipates rental prices will continue their ascent, though at a more moderated pace than the dramatic rises seen since 2021, attributed to a tightening supply scenario.

Geographically, the rental landscape saw variances, with increases noted in pivotal regions like the New York City metro, San Francisco Bay area, and Chicago. Conversely, areas such as the greater Los Angeles, Philadelphia, and Detroit witnessed declines. 

The overarching trend of rising rents is closely linked to a notable deceleration in construction starts, amidst climbing costs and a dip in demand. This suggests a looming supply shortage as the market endeavors to assimilate the wave of spaces introduced at the tail end of 2023 and early 2024.